It is common knowledge that Canadais one of the most multicultural countries around the world. Proof of this multiculturalism can be seen by walking in any street of downtown Torontoat any time and noticing all of the people with different physical features who were born in another country or were born here in Canada, but their parents are from other countries.

This blog post shares some basic information about dual or multiple Citizenship and how it can have some important implications in our lives. It was written by JFCY PLE Team volunteer Lina Maria Sanchez.

SCENARIO

Ivan is 16 years old and was born in Ukrainewhen his parents, Vera and Dan, were there for some long vacations. His parents came back to Canadawhen he was one year of age. Last year, when the family decided to revisit Ivan`s birth country, they were shocked to learn that he was still considered to be a Ukrainian citizen and as a result, he was subject to military service. They also learned that Ukraine did not recognize dual citizenship.

Photo source: http://panthera9105.wordpress.com/%C2%BFque-es-microsoft-passport-network/
                                    

INFORMATION

What does dual citizenship mean?

If you have dual citizenship, it means that you are recognized as a citizen in more than one country.[1]Dual citizenship is the result of each independent nation being able to decide who to recognize as a citizen.[2] Dual citizenship means that being recognized as a citizen in one country does not prevent you from being recognized as a citizen in another country as well.

Canada has allowed dual citizenship since February 14, 1977.

Photo source: http://quadroframing.ca/passportphotos.html

When will a person be recognized as a dual citizen?

Individual countries have their own laws to establish the criteria for a person to become a citizen. These laws will usually include information on how to apply for citizenship and may even list certain situations where a person will automatically be treated as a citizen of the country without bringing a formal application. For example, if you were born in a particular country, it may mean that you are automatically treated as a citizen of that country depending on the laws of that country.[3]

In addition to birth in a country, here are some possible ways one may acquire citizenship:

  • an application is made by an individual for foreign citizenship
  • the individual has resided in a foreign country for an extended period of time
  • the individual has family in a foreign country
  • the individual is married to a citizen of the foreign country [4]

In Ivan’s situation, he may be a Ukrainian citizen because he was born In Ukraine Territory. Ivan may also be a Canadian citizen because his parents are Canadian citizens.

It is important to note that each country’s laws can either allow citizens to have dual citizenship or can take away the citizenship of anyone who obtains citizenship from another country.[5]

What kind of advantages does Ivan have because of his two nationalities?

  • unrestricted travel with his parents (because he is under 18 years of age) between both of the countries
  • more employment opportunities in the future given his ability to work in both countries
  • access to a variety of social benefits and programs, such as education and health care, in both countries
  • unrestricted residency with his parents (because he is under 18 years of age) in both countries
  • a greater personal connection with both countries[6]

 What kind of disadvantages does Ivan have because of his two nationalities?

  • He may be subjected to the laws of either country in the same way as any other citizen even if he is not living there full-time.
  • If he gets married in the future, his marriage may not be legally recognized in the other country (although, Canada does recognize foreign marriages as legally valid).
  • In addition, if he gets divorced or obtains any child custody orders in the future, these court documents may not be recognized in the other country.
  • He may be forced to repay any educational costs to one of the countries where he may have attended school in that country or that country helped him pay for school elsewhere
  • his citizenship in one country may not be recognized in the other country
  • When he is older, he may be forced to pay taxes in both countries
  • he may be required to register for military service in one or both of the countries[7]

For example, Ivan may be legally required to register for military service in Ukraine when he turns 18 years of age. This obligation may be enforced even if he is just visiting Ukraine and permanently resides in Canada. If he doesn’t comply with this requirement, he could face imprisonment or be forced to register for military service when he tries to leave Ukraine or when he comes back at some point in the future.[8] To avoid this kind of negative result, Ivan may decide he wants to permanently stay in Canada and can renounce his Ukrainian citizenship before the age he would be required to register for military service.

The following websites provide some useful information about dual citizenship:

This blog post was written by Lina Maria Sanchez, a lawyer in her native Columbia. Lina Maria is a volunteer member of the PLE Team.  Editing and citations were done by Emily Slinger, a law student intern at JFCY.